Mifflin-St Jeor vs Harris-Benedict: Which Formula Is Better?

Mifflin-St Jeor vs Harris-Benedict: Which Formula Is Better?
CCCalorCalc
CalorCalc journalNutrition notes
Guides

Mifflin-St Jeor vs Harris-Benedict: Which Formula Is Better?

Practical nutrition guidance for making everyday menu choices with more context and less guesswork.

Two matching stacks of blank index cards with a calculator, pencil, and tape measure on a light desk

Two calorie calculators can give you two different numbers for the same body. The reason is usually the formula underneath. The most common comparison is Mifflin-St Jeor vs Harris-Benedict, the two most widely used equations for estimating basal metabolic rate (BMR), which is the energy your body uses at rest.

The short answer: For most healthy adults, Mifflin-St Jeor is the better default. It was built from more recent data, and a 2005 systematic review found it more likely than other common equations to land within 10% of measured resting energy use. Harris-Benedict is still widely used, especially the 1984 revised version, and the two often differ by only about 50 to 100 calories a day. Both are estimates.

Quick Comparison

Mifflin-St JeorHarris-Benedict
Published19901918 and 1919 (revised in 1984)
InputsSex, weight, height, ageSex, weight, height, age
Based on498 healthy adults, measured by indirect calorimetryEarly 20th century measurements, recalculated in 1984
Best known forCommon default in modern calculatorsLong clinical history
Main cautionCan be less accurate at body extremesOriginal version tends to run high

What Is the Mifflin-St Jeor Equation?

The Mifflin-St Jeor equation estimates BMR from your weight, height, age, and sex. It comes from a 1990 study of 498 healthy people aged 19 to 78, including both normal-weight and obese participants, whose resting energy use was measured directly.

The formulas (weight in kilograms, height in centimeters, age in years):

Men:   BMR = (10 x weight) + (6.25 x height) - (5 x age) + 5
Women: BMR = (10 x weight) + (6.25 x height) - (5 x age) - 161

To use pounds and inches, convert first: kilograms equal pounds divided by 2.205, and centimeters equal inches multiplied by 2.54.

The 1990 authors also reported that the original 1919 Harris-Benedict equations overestimated measured resting energy use by about 5% in their sample.

What Is the Harris-Benedict Equation?

The Harris-Benedict equation also estimates BMR from sex, weight, height, and age. It was first published in 1918 and 1919 by James Arthur Harris and Francis Benedict, and Roza and Shizgal revised the coefficients in 1984.

Original vs Revised Versions

Many calculators do not say which version they use, so it helps to know both.

Harris-Benedict Formula for Women

Original (1919):  BMR = 655.0955 + (9.5634 x weight) + (1.8496 x height) - (4.6756 x age)
Revised (1984):   BMR = 447.593 + (9.247 x weight) + (3.098 x height) - (4.330 x age)

Harris-Benedict Formula for Men

Original (1919):  BMR = 66.4730 + (13.7516 x weight) + (5.0033 x height) - (6.7550 x age)
Revised (1984):   BMR = 88.362 + (13.397 x weight) + (4.799 x height) - (5.677 x age)

A quick way to tell the versions apart: the revised formulas start with 447.593 for women and 88.362 for men. If a calculator does not state which version it uses, check its constants or its documentation.

Mifflin-St Jeor vs Harris-Benedict: Same Person, Both Formulas

Here is how the equations compare for two sample profiles. These are illustrative examples calculated from the formulas above, not measured values.

ProfileMifflin-St JeorHarris-Benedict (revised)Harris-Benedict (original)
Woman, 30 years, 165 cm, 65 kgabout 1,370 kcalabout 1,430 kcalabout 1,442 kcal
Man, 30 years, 180 cm, 80 kgabout 1,780 kcalabout 1,854 kcalabout 1,864 kcal

In both cases the Harris-Benedict results are higher, by roughly 60 to 85 calories. That is a small gap, and it is well inside the normal error of any estimating equation. For most people, the formula matters less than how accurately they choose an activity level and track results afterward.

Which Formula Is More Accurate?

For most healthy adults, Mifflin-St Jeor is the stronger default. A 2005 systematic review in the Journal of the American Dietetic Association (Frankenfield and colleagues) compared several predictive equations against measured resting metabolic rate and found Mifflin-St Jeor was more likely to land within 10% of the measured value.

Some points to keep in mind:

  • No equation is exact. Muscle mass, genetics, medical conditions, and body composition all affect real BMR.
  • Results can be less reliable at the extremes, such as very high muscle mass, severe obesity, or older age. The Katch-McArdle equation, which uses lean body mass, is another option if you know your body fat percentage.
  • Harris-Benedict is not “wrong.” The revised version is still used in many clinical and educational settings, and in many cases the difference is small.

How to Turn BMR Into Daily Calories

BMR is only the energy you use at rest. To estimate daily calorie needs (often called TDEE, or total daily energy expenditure), multiply BMR by an activity factor:

Activity levelMultiplier
Sedentary1.2
Lightly active1.375
Moderately active1.55
Active1.725
Very active1.9

Using the woman in the example above with Mifflin-St Jeor (1,370 kcal) and a lightly active level, the estimate is about 1,884 calories per day (1,370 x 1.375). The same person with revised Harris-Benedict (1,430 kcal) would land near 1,966, a gap of roughly 80 calories.

Treat the result as a starting point. Track your intake and weight over two to three weeks, then adjust.

Why Your Calculator May Show a Different Number

If two tools disagree, check these first:

  • Different formula: One may use Mifflin-St Jeor and the other Harris-Benedict.
  • Different Harris-Benedict version: Original or revised.
  • Different activity multipliers: Some tools use their own scale.
  • Rounding or unit conversion: Pounds, inches, and centimeters can add small errors.
  • Extra steps: Some calculators add a goal adjustment (such as a deficit) before showing a result.

Next Step: Estimate Your Own Needs

Once you have chosen a formula, you can estimate your daily calories step by step. Our guide on how to calculate your daily calorie needs at home walks through the process. If you want to see how a specific drink fits into your day, the CalorCalc Starbucks Calorie Calculator covers calories in Starbucks drinks.

FAQs

Is Mifflin-St Jeor more accurate than Harris-Benedict?

For most healthy adults, Mifflin-St Jeor tends to be more accurate. A 2005 systematic review found it was more likely to land within 10% of measured resting energy use. Both are still estimates.

What is the Harris-Benedict formula for women?

The revised formula is: BMR = 447.593 + (9.247 x weight in kg) + (3.098 x height in cm) – (4.330 x age in years). The original 1919 version uses different constants, starting with 655.0955.

Which formula do calculators use?

It varies. Many modern calculators default to Mifflin-St Jeor, but some use Harris-Benedict (original or revised). Check the tool’s notes or its constants.

What is the difference between BMR and TDEE?

BMR is the energy your body uses at rest. TDEE is BMR multiplied by an activity factor, which estimates total daily needs.

Can I use either formula for weight loss?

Both give a maintenance estimate. A calorie goal for weight change is a separate decision and depends on personal factors, so speak with a healthcare professional if you are unsure.

Conclusion

When comparing Mifflin-St Jeor vs Harris-Benedict, Mifflin-St Jeor is the better default for most healthy adults, while Harris-Benedict (especially the 1984 revision) gives similar results within a small margin. The bigger factors are an honest activity level and tracking your results over time. Pick one formula, use it consistently, and adjust based on what you observe.

This article provides general nutrition information, not medical advice. Equations estimate average needs and may not suit everyone. Speak with a doctor or registered dietitian about your personal calorie needs.